Back to all transcripts

29 Nov Delta Air Lines flight 2196 nearly landed on occupied taxiway

A Delta MD-88 is ordered to go around after inadvertently lining up with an occupied taxiway.

2017-12-14 Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport (KATL)

Summary

On November 29, 2017, Delta Flight 2196 was cleared to land at Atlanta Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport but mistakenly aligned with a parallel taxiway. A sharp-eyed tower controller noticed the error and ordered an immediate go-around just as the aircraft was descending over other taxiing planes. The flight was successfully re-sequenced and landed safely on a different runway shortly after.

Analysis

This incident highlights one of the most dangerous errors in terminal operations: the taxiway landing alignment. Delta Flight 2196, a McDonnell Douglas MD-88, was on approach to Runway 9L at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport (ATL). Due to the parallel nature of the runways and taxiways, and potentially influenced by lighting or pilot fatigue, the crew mistakenly lined up their approach with Taxiway November instead of the runway.

The recording captures the critical moment of intervention. While the controller is busy managing ground traffic—specifically Delta 1973 and Delta 331, who were actually on the taxiway system—he identifies that Delta 2196 is not where it should be. The command "Delta 2196, go around" is issued firmly. The controller then provides the reason: "It looks like you were over the taxiway." This is a significant observation because, at a busy hub like Atlanta, taxiways are frequently occupied by aircraft waiting to take off or crossing to terminals; a landing there would likely result in a catastrophic collision.

The incident is notable for the controller's situational awareness. In the aftermath of the Air Canada 759 near-miss at San Francisco earlier that year, the aviation industry was on high alert for taxiway misalignments. By catching the error before the wheels touched down, the controller prevented a repeat of that near-disaster.

Following the go-around, the aircraft is handed back to Approach Control. Interestingly, the controllers decide to switch the aircraft to Runway 10 for its second attempt. This "change of scenery" is often used by ATC after a significant pilot error to break the "expectation bias" that may have led to the first mistake, ensuring the crew has a completely fresh mental model for the second approach. Technical instructions for the ILS (Instrument Landing System) frequency and speed reductions (170 knots) show the transition back to a standard, controlled environment.

View Ratings Overall: 7/10
Overall 7 Spicy 7 Rare 6 Competence 9 Fame 5 Educational 8 Entertainment 6 Historical 4 Emotional 5
Tap any message below to get an AI-powered explanation of what's happening

Original ATC Communication

Plain English Translation

ATC
Delta 1973, turn left on November and hold short of Papa.
ATC
Delta 1973, make a left onto taxiway November and stop just before you reach taxiway Papa.
PILOT (DELTA 1973)
Left on November, hold short of Papa, Delta 1973.
PILOT (DELTA 1973)
Left on November and stopping short of Papa, Delta 1973.
ATC
Delta 331, at Papa cross runway nine left, join Lima, and contact Ground on .75.
ATC
Delta 331, when you get to taxiway Papa, drive across runway nine left, get onto taxiway Lima, and then switch your radio over to the ground controllers on frequency 121.75.
PILOT (DELTA 331)
At Papa, cross nine left, join Lima, .75, Delta 331.
PILOT (DELTA 331)
Crossing nine left at Papa, then onto Lima and over to ground on .75, Delta 331.
ATC
Delta 2196, go around.
ATC
Delta 2196, abort your landing and climb back up.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Delta 2196 is on the go.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Delta 2196 is powering up and climbing away.
ATC
It looks like you were over the taxiway. Delta 2196, turn right heading 180.
ATC
It looks like you were lined up with the taxiway instead of the runway. Delta 2196, turn right to a south heading of 180 degrees.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Right heading 180, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Turning right to heading 180, Delta 2196.
ATC
Delta 2196, continue right turn heading 200.
ATC
Delta 2196, keep turning right until you are facing heading 200.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Heading 200, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Heading 200, Delta 2196.
ATC
Delta 2196, maintain 4,000.
ATC
Delta 2196, stay at 4,000 feet.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Four thousand, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Level at four thousand, Delta 2196.
ATC
Delta 2196, they're going to be taking you now to runway one zero. Turn right heading 275. Radar contact. 4,000 with Atlanta.
ATC
Delta 2196, they are going to guide you to runway one-zero now. Turn right to heading 275. We have you on radar. Stay at 4,000 feet and check in with Atlanta approach.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Alright, 275, runway one zero, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Okay, heading 275 for runway one-zero, Delta 2196.
ATC
Delta 2196, runway one zero localizer frequency is 111.55.
ATC
Delta 2196, the radio frequency for the runway one-zero landing guidance system is 111.55.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
111.55, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Setting the radio to 111.55, Delta 2196.
ATC
Delta 2196, maintain 210 knots.
ATC
Delta 2196, keep your speed at 210 knots.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Maintain 210, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Holding at 210 knots, Delta 2196.
ATC
Delta 2196, contact Approach on 118.35.
ATC
Delta 2196, switch over and talk to the approach controllers on 118.35.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
118.35, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Switching to 118.35, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
I'm sorry, go ahead, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
My apologies, go ahead with your message, Delta 2196.
ATC
Just making sure you were checking in. Delta 2196, on approach runway one zero now will be your runway. One zero localizer's 111.55.
ATC
Just making sure you had arrived on this frequency. Delta 2196, you'll be landing on runway 10. The radio frequency for that runway's guidance beam is 111.55.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Got 111.55 for 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Got 111.55 dialed in for Delta 2196.
ATC
Delta 2196, descend and maintain 3,000.
ATC
Delta 2196, drop down and stay at 3,000 feet.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
3,000, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Down to 3,000, Delta 2196.
ATC
Delta 2196, turn right heading 360.
ATC
Delta 2196, turn right to a heading of due north.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Right 360, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Right turn to north, Delta 2196.
ATC
Delta 2196, seven miles from CP, turn right heading 075. Maintain 3,000 until established on the localizer. Cleared ILS runway one zero approach.
ATC
Delta 2196, seven miles from the checkpoint, turn right to heading 075. Stay at 3,000 feet until you're lined up with the runway's guidance beam. You're cleared for the instrument landing on runway 10.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
075, cleared ILS one zero, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Heading 075, cleared for the runway 10 instrument landing, Delta 2196.
ATC
Delta 2196, reduce speed to 170. Good rate back on the speed.
ATC
Delta 2196, slow down to 170 knots. Good job getting that speed down quickly.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Slowing to 170, Delta 2196.
PILOT (DELTA 2196)
Slowing down to 170 knots, this is Delta flight 2196.

What's happening here?

0:00
0:00