Back to all transcripts

Delta 1086 off runway LGA 3-5-15

Delta Flight 1086 skids off a snowy runway at LaGuardia, resulting in a fuel leak.

2015-03-05 LaGuardia Airport (LGA), New York City

Summary

On March 5, 2015, Delta Flight 1086, a McDonnell Douglas MD-88, overran Runway 13 at LaGuardia Airport during a snowstorm. The aircraft crashed through a perimeter fence and came to rest on an embankment near Flushing Bay, causing a significant fuel leak. This recording captures the Tower's attempts to contact the aircraft and the subsequent emergency closure of the airport.

Analysis

The incident involving Delta Flight 1086 occurred during challenging winter weather conditions at New York's LaGuardia Airport. The aircraft, arriving from Atlanta, failed to maintain directional control after touchdown on a snow-covered Runway 13. The transcript begins with routine departures and arrivals, but the tone shifts abruptly when the Tower controller repeatedly attempts to hail Delta 1086 with no response. This "dead air" from a recently landed aircraft is a primary indicator to controllers that a significant event has occurred.

A notable aspect of this recording is that the Tower is not the first to confirm the crash; a ground vehicle (Car 100) provides the critical information that the runway is closed and an aircraft is off the pavement. In low-visibility winter conditions, controllers often rely on ground personnel to verify the status of the airfield. The report from the ground crew that the aircraft was "leaking fuel on the left side... heavily" escalated the situation from a runway excursion to a potential fire emergency, necessitating the immediate dispatch of Crash Rescue teams.

The controller demonstrates high competence by immediately halting all traffic. He orders Delta 1999 and Delta 2522, both on final approach, to "go around" instantly. This prevents further aircraft from landing on a contaminated and obstructed runway. The transition of the airport to a "closed" status is handled efficiently, with the controller managing the expectations of other pilots (like Air Canada 4979 and JetBlue 971) who are stuck on taxiways or de-icing pads.

Technically, the NTSB later determined that the cause of the accident was the pilot's use of excessive reverse thrust in the snowy conditions, which caused the MD-88's rudder to become ineffective, leading the plane to veer off the runway. The "3-4" code mentioned by the ground vehicle is a specific emergency designation for an aircraft accident. While the aircraft was severely damaged and the wing ruptured, all 132 passengers and crew evacuated via the over-wing exits, with only minor injuries reported. This event remains a key case study in winter operations and the aerodynamic sensitivities of the MD-80 series.

View Ratings Overall: 9/10
Overall 9 Spicy 8 Rare 7 Competence 9 Fame 8 Educational 8 Entertainment 7 Historical 6 Emotional 7
Tap any message below to get an AI-powered explanation of what's happening

Original ATC Communication

Plain English Translation

LGA TOWER
JetBlue 319, you ready for departure?
LGA TOWER
JetBlue 319, are you ready to take off?
JETBLUE 319
JetBlue 319 is ready.
JETBLUE 319
JetBlue 319 is ready to go.
LGA TOWER
JetBlue 319, Runway 4, RVR touchdown 4500, rollout 6000. Wind 020 at 10. Runway 4, cleared for takeoff.
LGA TOWER
JetBlue 319, use Runway 4. Visibility is 4,500 feet at the start and 6,000 feet at the end. Wind is 10 knots from the north. Runway 4, you're cleared for takeoff.
JETBLUE 319
Cleared for takeoff, Runway 4, JetBlue 319. Wind check?
JETBLUE 319
Cleared for takeoff on Runway 4, JetBlue 319. Can we get a quick wind update?
LGA TOWER
Wind 020 at 10.
LGA TOWER
The wind is from the north-northeast at 10 knots.
LGA TOWER
JetBlue 319, contact Departure. Good day.
LGA TOWER
JetBlue 319, switch over to the departure controllers now. Have a good flight.
JETBLUE 319
JetBlue 319, good day.
JETBLUE 319
JetBlue 319, thanks, have a good one.
DELTA 1999
LaGuardia Tower, Delta 1999 with you on the ILS 13.
DELTA 1999
LaGuardia Tower, this is Delta 1999, we’re lined up for Runway 13 using the instrument landing system.
LGA TOWER
Delta 1999, LaGuardia Tower. Number one for the field. Wind 020 at 12. Runway 13, cleared to land. Braking action reported good by an Airbus 319. Runway 13 RVR touchdown 6000, rollout 3500.
LGA TOWER
Delta 1999, LaGuardia Tower. You’re first in line to land. Wind is 12 knots. Runway 13, you're cleared to land. A previous pilot said the brakes work well. Visibility is 6,000 feet at the start and 3,500 feet at the end.
DELTA 1999
Cleared to land 13, Delta 1999.
DELTA 1999
Cleared to land on Runway 13, Delta 1999.
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086?
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086, are you there?
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086?
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086?
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086?
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086, do you hear me?
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086?
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086?
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086, Tower, you with me?
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086, this is the Tower, are you still on this radio channel?
GROUND VEHICLE
Car 100, cross 4 at Papa.
GROUND VEHICLE
Car 100, I’m crossing Runway 4 at the Papa taxiway.
LGA TOWER
Car 100, cross Runway 4 at Taxiway Papa.
LGA TOWER
Car 100, you are cleared to cross Runway 4 at the Papa taxiway.
GROUND VEHICLE
Car 100 crossing.
GROUND VEHICLE
Car 100 is now crossing the runway.
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086, Tower?
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086, this is the Tower, do you hear me?
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, Car 100. Runway 13 is closed.
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, this is Car 100. I am declaring Runway 13 closed.
LGA TOWER
Tower.
LGA TOWER
This is the Tower, go ahead.
GROUND VEHICLE
Team Red to go on to 13.
GROUND VEHICLE
I'm sending the emergency response team out onto Runway 13.
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, do you copy Car 100? Runway 13 is closed.
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, do you hear Car 100? I said Runway 13 is closed!
LGA TOWER
Car—Delta—Car 100, you said Runway 13 is closed?
LGA TOWER
Car—Delta—Car 100, did you just say Runway 13 is closed?
GROUND VEHICLE
Affirmative. 13 is closed.
GROUND VEHICLE
That’s correct. 13 is closed.
GROUND VEHICLE
Team Red, Tower.
GROUND VEHICLE
Emergency Team to Tower.
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, you have an aircraft off the runway.
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, you have a plane that has crashed off the side of the runway.
LGA TOWER
Delta 1999, go around. Climb and maintain 2000.
LGA TOWER
Delta 1999, abort your landing! Pull up and climb to 2000 feet.
DELTA 1999
1999 going around.
DELTA 1999
Delta 1999 is aborting the landing and climbing.
GROUND VEHICLE
The airport is closed. The airport is closed. We've got a 3-4.
GROUND VEHICLE
The airport is closed. Shut the whole airport down. We have a major aircraft accident.
GROUND VEHICLE
Car 100, say again?
GROUND VEHICLE
Car 100, can you repeat that?
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, you have an aircraft off 31 on the north vehicle service road. Please advise Crash Rescue. LaGuardia Airport is closed at this time.
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, there's a plane off the end of runway 31 sitting on the north vehicle service road. Get the fire and rescue teams out here now. LaGuardia Airport is officially shut down.
DELTA 2522
LaGuardia Tower, Delta 2522 is on the ILS for 13.
DELTA 2522
LaGuardia Tower, this is Delta 2522, we're lined up and following the instrument guidance system for a landing on runway 13.
LGA TOWER
Delta 2522, LaGuardia Tower, go around.
LGA TOWER
Delta 2522, this is LaGuardia Tower—abort your landing immediately and climb away.
DELTA 2522
Going around, Delta 2522.
DELTA 2522
Aborting the landing and climbing out, Delta 2522.
LGA TOWER
Delta 1999, I'll have the go-around instructions for you in just a moment.
LGA TOWER
Delta 1999, stay with me, I'll give you directions on where to fly after your aborted landing in just a second.
DELTA 1999
Going around.
DELTA 1999
We're climbing away.
LGA TOWER
Delta 1999, turn left heading 070.
LGA TOWER
Delta 1999, turn left and fly a heading of 070 degrees.
DELTA 1999
070, Delta 1999.
DELTA 1999
Turning to 070, Delta 1999.
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, are you talking to the flight crew of the MD-80?
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, are you in radio contact with the pilots of that MD-80 jet?
LGA TOWER
I'm calling out for Delta 1086, no response.
LGA TOWER
I’m calling for Delta 1086 right now, but I'm getting no response.
GROUND VEHICLE
Okay, sir. He is—if he comes up, he is leaking fuel on the left side of his aircraft heavily.
GROUND VEHICLE
Understood, sir. If you get through to him, let him know he is leaking fuel heavily from the left side of his aircraft.
LGA TOWER
He's leaking fuel, you said?
LGA TOWER
Did you say he's leaking fuel?
GROUND VEHICLE
Affirm. His wing is ruptured.
GROUND VEHICLE
That’s right. His wing has been torn open.
DELTA 2522
Delta 2522 would like to switch over to Departure.
DELTA 2522
Delta 2522 would like to switch radio frequencies over to the departure controllers.
LGA TOWER
I'll get you that frequency in just a moment, Delta 2522.
LGA TOWER
I'll give you that next radio channel in just a second, Delta twenty-five twenty-two.
LGA TOWER
Delta 1999, contact Approach 134.9.
LGA TOWER
Delta nineteen ninety-nine, switch over to the approach controllers on one-thirty-four point nine.
DELTA 1999
34.9, Delta 1999.
DELTA 1999
One-thirty-four point nine, Delta nineteen ninety-nine.
LGA TOWER
Delta 2522, climb and maintain 3000. Turn left heading 070.
LGA TOWER
Delta twenty-five twenty-two, climb up and stay at three thousand feet. Turn left to a compass heading of zero-seven-zero.
DELTA 2522
Climb and maintain 3000, left turn heading 070, Delta 2522.
DELTA 2522
Climbing to stay at three thousand, left turn to heading zero-seven-zero, Delta twenty-five twenty-two.
LGA TOWER
Delta 2522, contact Approach 134.9.
LGA TOWER
Delta twenty-five twenty-two, switch over to the approach controllers on one-thirty-four point nine.
DELTA 2522
134.9, Delta 2522. So long.
DELTA 2522
One-thirty-four point nine, Delta twenty-five twenty-two. See ya.
ACA 4979
Tower, AC 4979. We understand the airport is closed?
ACA 4979
LaGuardia Tower, this is Air Canada forty-nine seventy-nine. Did we hear right that the airport is shut down?
LGA TOWER
Stand by, AC 4979.
LGA TOWER
Wait one second, Air Canada forty-nine seventy-nine.
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086, Tower, you with me?
LGA TOWER
Delta ten eighty-six, this is the Tower, can you hear me?
LGA TOWER
Delta 1086, are you with me?
LGA TOWER
Delta ten eighty-six, are you still on this radio channel?
LGA TOWER
AC 4979, LaGuardia Tower, you had a question?
LGA TOWER
Air Canada forty-nine seventy-nine, LaGuardia Tower, what was your question?
ACA 4979
AC 4979, we just overheard that the airport is closed.
ACA 4979
For Air Canada forty-nine seventy-nine, we just heard over the radio that the whole airport is closed.
LGA TOWER
Yes, sir. The airport's closed until further notice.
LGA TOWER
Yes, sir. The airport is shut down until we say otherwise.
ACA 4979
AC 4979, we're holding short here of Runway 4 at Alpha Alpha. Do you just want us to stay here until further notice?
ACA 4979
Air Canada forty-nine seventy-nine, we're parked right before Runway 4 on taxiway Alpha Alpha. Should we just stay put here until we hear more?
LGA TOWER
Yes, sir. Just remain this frequency and hold there for now. I'll have further for you shortly.
LGA TOWER
Yes, sir. Just stay on this radio channel and wait right where you are for now. I'll have more information for you in a moment.
ACA 4979
Okay.
ACA 4979
Understood.
JETBLUE 971
LaGuardia Tower, JetBlue 971. Are we still open?
JETBLUE 971
LaGuardia Tower, this is JetBlue 971. Is the airport still open for us?
LGA TOWER
Negative. The airport is closed until further notice.
LGA TOWER
No. The airport is completely shut down until further notice.
JETBLUE 971
Okay. We're de-icing right now. What do you recommend?
JETBLUE 971
All right. We're in the middle of spraying the wings for ice right now. What do you suggest we do?
LGA TOWER
Let me know your intentions. As of now, we're closed until further notice.
LGA TOWER
Just let me know what you're planning to do. As of right now, we're closed until further notice.
JETBLUE 971
I'm ready to depart anytime you will. I'll just sit here and standby for you.
JETBLUE 971
I'm ready to take off whenever you're ready for me. I'll just sit here and wait for your word.
LGA TOWER
As you wish.
LGA TOWER
Whatever you'd like to do.
JETBLUE 971
Right.
JETBLUE 971
Got it.
LGA TOWER
AC 4979, you can shut down there if you want.
LGA TOWER
Air Canada 4979, you can turn off your engines right where you are if you want to.
ACA 4979
AC 4979.
ACA 4979
Air Canada 4979, copy that.
ACA 4979
Tower, AC 4979?
ACA 4979
Tower, this is Air Canada 4979 again?
LGA TOWER
Go ahead.
LGA TOWER
Go ahead.
ACA 4979
Yeah, not sure how long it's going to be, but if you'd like, you can shut it down.
ACA 4979
Yeah, we're not sure how long this delay will be, but if you'd like, we can go ahead and turn the engines off.
ACA 4979
Anyway we could go to—to the gate?
ACA 4979
Is there any way we could just head back to the terminal gate?
LGA TOWER
Sure. You can just return to Ground 121.7 and they'll work you back.
LGA TOWER
Sure. You can just switch back to the ground traffic controllers on frequency 121.7 and they’ll coordinate getting you back to the gate.
ACA 4979
Okay, Ground 21.7. Thanks.
ACA 4979
Okay, switching to ground control on 121.7. Thanks.
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, Car 1.
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, this is Car 1 calling.
LGA TOWER
Car 1, go ahead.
LGA TOWER
Go ahead, Car 1, I'm listening.
GROUND VEHICLE
I'm over here with the Delta aircraft. He's got a big fuel leak on the left wing. We're going to start getting the people out.
GROUND VEHICLE
I’m over here with the Delta plane. There’s a major fuel leak coming off the left wing. We’re going to start evacuating the passengers now.
LGA TOWER
Car 1, Roger. Aircraft is leaking fuel on the left wing. You're going to start deplaning people now?
LGA TOWER
Understood, Car 1. The plane is leaking fuel from the left wing. You are going to start getting everyone off the aircraft right now?
GROUND VEHICLE
That's correct.
GROUND VEHICLE
That’s correct.
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, Romeo's current with the airport closed. Romeo is current.
GROUND VEHICLE
Tower, the latest official airport update, code Romeo, is now active and shows the airport is closed. Romeo is the current report.

What's happening here?

0:00
0:00