Back to all transcripts

Re CommAir STOP the aircraft !!!

Kennedy Ground urgently orders a Comair aircraft to stop to prevent a major taxiway gridlock.

2007-09-30 John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK), New York

Summary

A Kennedy Ground controller uses an urgent tone to halt a Comair aircraft approaching a congested ramp entry at JFK Airport. The recording captures the logistical challenge of managing multiple aircraft from the same airline in a crowded taxiway environment. After the initial stop order, the controller works to reroute several flights to clear a bottleneck near taxiway Lima Alpha.

Analysis

This recording captures a high-stress moment for a ground controller at New York's John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK). The incident begins with the controller repeatedly and urgently calling for a Comair aircraft to "stop the aircraft" near taxiway Lima Alpha. This level of urgency usually suggests that an aircraft is about to enter a "lock-up" situation—a ground traffic jam where aircraft are positioned in a way that none can move without a complex series of tug maneuvers—or is approaching a restricted area without authorization.

The technical complexity of JFK’s ground operations is on full display here. The controller is managing multiple Comair flights (521, 613, and 279) simultaneously. Because these aircraft often look identical and use similar callsigns, identifying the specific "offender" requires the controller to ask for "your numbers" (flight number). The situation is further complicated by the presence of Air France 007, a "Heavy" aircraft, which reports being blocked by one of the smaller Comair regional jets.

The mention of "Lima Alpha" being "blocked by three aircraft" highlights the common issue of ramp saturation at busy hubs. At JFK, certain ramp entries lead to specific terminals; if those gates are full, aircraft must wait on the taxiways, which can quickly obstruct the flow of other traffic. The controller's decision to use "Guard" (the emergency frequency 121.5 MHz) or a similarly authoritative tone on the primary ground frequency demonstrates the critical need for immediate compliance to maintain airport efficiency.

Ultimately, the situation is resolved through proactive "re-sequencing." The controller directs Comair 613 through a series of turns—left at Kilo, right on Alpha, and holding short of Juliet—effectively moving them out of the way of the Air France heavy and clearing the bottleneck at the Lima Alpha entry point. This illustrates the "chess game" nature of ground control at one of the world's busiest airports.

View Ratings Overall: 6/10
Overall 6 Spicy 6 Rare 4 Competence 8 Fame 3 Educational 7 Entertainment 5 Historical 2 Emotional 3
Tap any message below to get an AI-powered explanation of what's happening

Original ATC Communication

Plain English Translation

ATC
Comair approaching Mike on Bravo, what’s your numbers? Comair approaching Mike on Bravo, what’s your numbers? Comair on Bravo approaching Lima Alpha—Comair aircraft on Bravo approaching Lima Alpha, this is Kennedy Ground on guard: Stop the aircraft, call 219. Comair on Bravo approaching Lima Alpha, stop the aircraft, contact Ground.
ATC
Comair plane approaching intersection Mike on taxiway Bravo, what’s your flight number? Comair near Mike on Bravo, identify yourself. Comair on Bravo heading toward the Lima Alpha ramp—Comair aircraft on Bravo, this is Kennedy Ground on the emergency channel: Stop the plane immediately and contact us on frequency 219. Comair approaching Lima Alpha, stop the aircraft and talk to Ground control.
COMAIR 521
Ground, Comair 521 short of Mike. Have we been cleared in?
COMAIR 521
Ground, this is Comair 521 waiting just before taxiway Mike. Have we been given permission to taxi in?
ATC
Comair 521, hold your position.
ATC
Comair 521, stay exactly where you are.
COMAIR 521
Yes, sir.
COMAIR 521
Understood, sir.
ATC
Comair, the aircraft short of Lima Alpha on Bravo, what’s your numbers?
ATC
Comair, the plane stopped just before the Lima Alpha area on taxiway Bravo, what is your flight number?
COMAIR 613
Comair 613.
COMAIR 613
We're Comair 613.
ATC
613, where are you parking?
ATC
613, which gate or ramp are you heading to?
COMAIR 613
Lima Alpha.
COMAIR 613
The Lima Alpha ramp.
ATC
All right, so we’ve got to wait for that guy. Taxi to Lima, taxi down and hold short of Hotel on Bravo.
ATC
All right, so we have to wait for that other plane. Taxi over to the Lima intersection, then head down the taxiway and stop just before you get to Hotel on Bravo.
COMAIR 613
Okay, taxi down Bravo short of Hotel, Comair 613.
COMAIR 613
Okay, taxiing down Bravo and stopping before the Hotel intersection, Comair 613.
ATC
Comair short of Mike, taxi to Lima.
ATC
Comair waiting before Mike, go ahead and taxi to the Lima intersection.
AIR FRANCE 007
Ground, Air France 007 heavy. We’ve got a small aircraft in front of us on Mike Alpha.
AIR FRANCE 007
Ground, this is the Air France 007 jumbo jet. We have a small plane stuck right in front of us here on the Mike Alpha taxiway.
COMAIR 613
Ground, Comair 613. Just curious why we’re going all the way to Hotel.
COMAIR 613
Ground, Comair 613. We're just curious why you're sending us all the way down to the Hotel taxiway.
ATC
Lima Alpha is blocked by three aircraft, sir. 613, just hold short of Kilo.
ATC
The Lima Alpha ramp is totally blocked by three other planes, sir. 613, just stop and wait before you hit the Kilo taxiway.
COMAIR 613
Short of Kilo now, Comair 613. And they’ve got a Mike entry for us now.
COMAIR 613
Stopping before Kilo now, Comair 613. And our company says they have an opening for us at the Mike entrance now.
ATC
Make a left at Kilo, right on Alpha, short of Juliet.
ATC
Turn left onto the Kilo taxiway, then right on Alpha, and stop just before you reach the Juliet intersection.
COMAIR 613
Left Kilo, right Alpha, short of Juliet, Comair 613.
COMAIR 613
Left on Kilo, right on Alpha, and stopping before Juliet. This is Comair 613.
COMAIR 279
Ground, Comair 279. We'd like to taxi here at Lima Alpha, holding short of Alpha.
COMAIR 279
Ground control, this is Comair 279. We’re ready to taxi out from the Lima Alpha area and we'll wait right before we hit the Alpha taxiway.
ATC
Comair 279, get back to you in a minute.
ATC
Comair 279, hold on, I'll be back with you in just a minute.
COMAIR 613
Comair 613, was that a right turn on Alpha?
COMAIR 613
Comair 613 here, just confirming—did you want us to make a right turn on Alpha?
ATC
Yes, right on Alpha, short of Juliet.
ATC
That’s correct, turn right on Alpha and stop just before the Juliet taxiway.
COMAIR 613
Okay, right Alpha, short of Juliet, Comair 613.
COMAIR 613
Okay, turning right on Alpha and stopping short of Juliet. Comair 613.
ATC
Comair 613, straight ahead, left Bravo, short Hotel.
ATC
Comair 613, continue straight ahead, then turn left on Bravo and stop before you get to the Hotel crossing.
COMAIR 613
Hotel, Comair 613. Thanks.
COMAIR 613
Stopping at Hotel, Comair 613. Thanks.

What's happening here?

0:00
0:00