Back to all transcripts

Re UPS 1354 (Birmingham, AL) crash audio

ATC audio capturing the final approach and immediate aftermath of the fatal UPS 1354 crash.

2014-02-18 Birmingham-Shuttlesworth International Airport (BHM), Birmingham, Alabama CW: This recording involves a fatal aircraft crash. Both crew members on UPS 1354 perished in the incident.

Summary

UPS Flight 1354, an Airbus A300, was performing a non-precision localizer approach to Runway 18 at Birmingham-Shuttlesworth International Airport because the primary runway was closed for maintenance. The transcript captures the routine clearance to land followed by the chilling realization from ground vehicles and the controller that the aircraft had crashed short of the runway. Both pilots were killed in the accident, which was later attributed to an unstable approach and pilot fatigue.

Analysis

The recording begins with a routine exchange as UPS 1354 prepares for arrival. A critical piece of context is the closure of Runway 6/24, the airport's primary runway equipped with a full Instrument Landing System (ILS). Because of this closure, the crew was forced to use Runway 18, which only offered a "Localizer" approach—a non-precision approach providing horizontal guidance but no vertical glide slope. This required the pilots to manually manage their descent rate based on altitude step-downs.

The tension shifts abruptly when an airport vehicle (Airport 12) asks, "Did you see that?" The controller's response is immediate and harrowing: "Airport 12, that was a crash." This marks the transition from a standard terminal environment to an emergency "Alert 3" status. The controller's professionalism remains intact as he directs emergency services ("Redbird") and manages other inbound traffic, specifically FedEx 1488, which was also planning for the same approach.

The technical cause of the crash was Controlled Flight Into Terrain (CFIT). The NTSB investigation revealed that the crew failed to properly monitor their altitude and sink rate during the non-precision approach. The crew had programmed the flight management computer incorrectly for the approach type, leading to a "vertical speed" descent that was too steep. Fatigue was also cited as a major contributing factor, as both pilots discussed being tired earlier in the flight.

This event is significant in aviation safety for highlighting the dangers of non-precision approaches at night and the ongoing issues of pilot fatigue in the cargo industry. Following the crash, there were renewed calls for cargo pilots to be included in the same rest requirements as passenger airline pilots. The transcript serves as a somber reminder of how quickly a routine flight can turn into a catastrophe when multiple small errors compound during a high-workload phase of flight.

View Ratings Overall: 10/10
Overall 10 Spicy 9 Rare 8 Competence 8 Fame 8 Educational 10 Entertainment 5 Historical 7 Emotional 9
Tap any message below to get an AI-powered explanation of what's happening

Original ATC Communication

Plain English Translation

UPS 1354 PILOT
Birmingham, UPS 1354. We’re at 11,000. We have Papa, looking for the localizer.
UPS 1354 PILOT
Birmingham, this is UPS 1354. We’re at 11,000 feet. We’ve received the latest weather update and we’re looking to pick up the runway guidance beam.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
UPS 1354 Heavy, Birmingham Tower. Descend and maintain 3,000. Runway 6 is still closed. You wanted the localizer 18?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
UPS 1354, our large cargo jet, this is Birmingham Tower. Descend and stay at 3,000 feet. Our main runway is still closed. Were you planning on using the guidance beam for runway 18?
UPS 1354 PILOT
Yes, sir. The localizer 18 will work.
UPS 1354 PILOT
Yes, sir. Using the guidance beam for runway 18 will work for us.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
UPS 1354 Heavy, turn 10 degrees right. Join the localizer, maintain 3,000.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
UPS 1354, turn 10 degrees to the right. Line up with the guidance beam and stay at 3,000 feet.
UPS 1354 PILOT
Right 10 degrees, join the localizer, maintain 3,000. 1354 Heavy.
UPS 1354 PILOT
Right 10 degrees, lining up with the beam, and holding 3,000 feet. UPS 1354.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
UPS 1354 Heavy is 11 miles from Baskin. Maintain 2,500 until established on the localizer. Cleared localizer 18 approach.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
UPS 1354, you are 11 miles from the Baskin waypoint. Stay at 2,500 feet until you are locked onto the guidance beam. You are authorized for the runway 18 landing approach.
UPS 1354 PILOT
2,500 until established, cleared for the localizer 18 approach. UPS 1354 Heavy.
UPS 1354 PILOT
2,500 until we’re locked on, authorized for the runway 18 approach. UPS 1354.
FEDEX 1488 PILOT
Birmingham, FedEx 1488?
FEDEX 1488 PILOT
Birmingham, this is FedEx 1488, do you copy?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
FedEx 1488, Birmingham.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
FedEx 1488, this is Birmingham Tower.
FEDEX 1488 PILOT
Yeah, for our planning, sir, how long is 6-24 going to be closed, or should we plan on 18?
FEDEX 1488 PILOT
Yeah, just for our planning, sir, how much longer is the main runway going to be closed, or should we prepare for runway 18?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
It should be closed for about another 15 minutes. UPS 1354 Heavy, change to my frequency, 119.9.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
It should be closed for about another 15 minutes. UPS 1354, switch over to my other radio frequency on 119.9.
UPS 1354 PILOT
119.9. 1354.
UPS 1354 PILOT
Switching to 119.9. UPS 1354.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
UPS 1354 Heavy, Runway 18, cleared to land. Wind calm.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
UPS 1354, you are authorized to land on runway 18. The wind is completely still.
UPS 1354 PILOT
18, cleared to land. 1354 Heavy.
UPS 1354 PILOT
Authorized to land on 18. UPS 1354.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 15, Tower.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport ground vehicle 15, this is the Tower.
AIRPORT 12
Tower, Airport 12 plus 2. Go ahead.
AIRPORT 12
Tower, this is Airport unit 12 and two other vehicles. Go ahead.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 12, are we on schedule to open back up at 10:00 Zulu?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 12, are we still on track to reopen the runway at 10:00 AM international time?
AIRPORT 12
Affirm. They’re very close to the end right now.
AIRPORT 12
Yes. The crews are very close to finishing the work right now.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Roger.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Understood.
AIRPORT 12
Tower, Airport 12. Did you see that?
AIRPORT 12
Tower, this is Airport 12. Did you see that?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 12, that was a crash. UPS 1354 Heavy crashed on the hill.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 12, that was a crash. A large UPS cargo jet, flight 1354, just crashed on the hill.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Attention, attention. Alert 3, airport crash. Aircraft crashed off three-mile final, Runway 18.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Emergency, emergency. We have a major aircraft crash. A plane has gone down three miles from landing on Runway 18.
AIRPORT 11
Birmingham Tower, Airport 11.
AIRPORT 11
Birmingham Tower, this is Airport unit 11.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Redbird, Airport Authority, aircraft crashed three-mile final, Runway 18. It is an Airbus 306. Redbird copy, two-mile final, Runway 18.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Fire crews and Airport Authority, a plane crashed three miles from the runway. It’s an Airbus 306. Fire crews, confirm you heard the location is two miles from the runway.
REDBIRD 27
Birmingham, we’re doing about 18,500 right now. Is that good?
REDBIRD 27
Birmingham, we’re operating on radio channel 18.5 right now. Is that working for you?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 12, go ahead. Airport 11, did you call?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 12, speak. Airport 11, were you trying to reach me?
AIRPORT 11
Yeah, standby, Tower. I'm trying to figure out what we need to do.
AIRPORT 11
Yes, hold on a second, Tower. I'm trying to figure out what our emergency response needs to be.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 11, roger.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Understood, Airport 11.
AIRPORT 11
Tower, was that UPS?
AIRPORT 11
Tower, was that a UPS plane?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 11, affirmative.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 11, yes it was.
AIRPORT 11
Thank you very much.
AIRPORT 11
Thank you very much.
AIRPORT 4
Tower, Airport 4 would like north on Bravo, cross 6-24 when available.
AIRPORT 4
Tower, this is Airport vehicle 4. I'd like to head north on taxiway Bravo and cross runway 6-24 when you have a gap.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 4, proceed north on Bravo, cross 6-24.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 4, go ahead and proceed north on taxiway Bravo and cross runway 6-24.
AIRPORT 4
North on Bravo, crossing 6-24.
AIRPORT 4
Heading north on Bravo and crossing runway 6-24 now.
AIRPORT 11
Tower, Airport 11 would also like north on Bravo, cross 6-24.
AIRPORT 11
Tower, Airport vehicle 11 would also like to go north on taxiway Bravo and cross runway 6-24.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 11, proceed north on Bravo, cross 6-24.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 11, you're clear to head north on taxiway Bravo and cross runway 6-24.
AIRPORT 11
North on Bravo, 6-24. Airport 11.
AIRPORT 11
North on Bravo and crossing 6-24. This is Airport 11.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 15, Tower.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport vehicle 15, this is the Tower.
AIRPORT 15
Go for 15. Airport 12 plus 2 off the runway.
AIRPORT 15
This is 15, go ahead. Airport 12 and two other vehicles are now clear of the runway.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 12 plus 2, advise when we can reopen the runway. I’ve got FedEx inbound; I need to use the ILS.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 12 and company, let me know the moment we can reopen the runway. I have a FedEx plane arriving and I need the precision landing system clear for them.
AIRPORT 12
Affirmative. You can use that runway, it's clear. Back open.
AIRPORT 12
That’s correct. You can use the runway now; it’s completely clear and back open.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Roger that, joined and open. Tower, go for 15.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Understood, the runway is back in service and open. Tower calling 15 again, go ahead.
AIRPORT 15
Airport 15, go ahead.
AIRPORT 15
Airport 15 here, go for it.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
I thought you had called me earlier. Did you still need me?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
I thought I heard you calling for me earlier. Did you still need something?
AIRPORT 15
Disregard. I just wanted to make sure the runway was open and clear.
AIRPORT 15
Never mind. I was just calling to make sure the runway was officially open and clear.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
15 copy.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Unit 15, I’ve got that.
AIRPORT 4
Tower, Airport 4 and 11 would like to cross the approach of 18.
AIRPORT 4
Tower, this is Airport Vehicle 4. Unit 11 and I would like to drive across the landing path for Runway 18.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Ground, Redbird 27. Redbird 27, Tower.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Ground crews, calling Redbird 27. Redbird 27, this is the Tower.
REDBIRD 27
This is Redbird 27. Can you give us more information on this?
REDBIRD 27
This is Redbird 27. Can you give us any more details on what’s happening?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Redbird 27, UPS Airbus crashed about a two-mile final, Runway 18.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Redbird 27, a UPS Airbus has crashed about two miles out from the end of Runway 18.
REDBIRD 27
Are we clear to go to our standby position? The aircraft did not come to the airport.
REDBIRD 27
Should we head to our emergency standby position? It sounds like the plane didn't actually reach the airport grounds.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
So it’s already crashed?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Wait, so you're saying it's already crashed?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Affirmative.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
That’s correct.
REDBIRD 27
Redbird 27, received.
REDBIRD 27
Redbird 27, understood.
FEDEX 1488 PILOT
Birmingham, FedEx 1488. We’re with you at 11,600 for 11,000, and we copied. We slowed down to 230 knots.
FEDEX 1488 PILOT
Birmingham, this is FedEx 1488. We're currently at 11,600 feet dropping down to 11,000, and we heard the news. We’ve slowed our speed to 230 knots.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
FedEx 1488, Birmingham. Descend and maintain 3,000. Runway 6 is now open. Expect ILS Runway 6 approach.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
FedEx 1488, Birmingham. Go ahead and drop down to 3,000 feet. Runway 6 is open now, so plan on using the instrument landing system to come in on that runway.
FEDEX 1488 PILOT
Okay, ILS 6 approach and descend down to 3,000. FedEx 1488.
FEDEX 1488 PILOT
Okay, using the instrument landing for Runway 6 and dropping down to 3,000 feet. FedEx 1488.
AIRPORT 4
Tower, 4 and 11 would like to cross approach 18.
AIRPORT 4
Tower, vehicles 4 and 11 are still looking to cross the landing path for Runway 18.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport vehicle calling, say again?
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
To the airport vehicle calling, could you say that again?
AIRPORT 4
4 and 11 would like to cross approach 18.
AIRPORT 4
Units 4 and 11 would like to drive across the landing path for Runway 18.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 4 and 11, cross Runway 18.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Birmingham Tower to airport vehicles 4 and 11: you're clear to drive across Runway 18.
AIRPORT 4
Crossing 18, Airport 4 and 11.
AIRPORT 4
Driving across 18 now, this is Airport 4 and 11.
AIRPORT 4
Tower, 4 and 11 are off movement area in the safety area.
AIRPORT 4
Tower, 4 and 11 are off the active runways and taxiways, staying in the designated safe zone.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Airport 4 and 11, roger.
BIRMINGHAM TOWER
Got it, units 4 and 11.

What's happening here?

0:00
0:00