Back to all transcripts

Runway Incursion at KPHL

A US Airways pilot crosses an active runway without clearance, sparking a heated argument with ATC.

2007-07-30 Philadelphia International Airport (KPHL)

Summary

A US Airways flight at Philadelphia International Airport (KPHL) mistakenly enters an active runway while another aircraft is landing. The controller frantically attempts to stop the aircraft, leading to a tense dispute over whether a crossing clearance was actually issued. The incident highlights the dangers of communication breakdowns during complex ground taxi operations.

Analysis

The incident occurred at Philadelphia International Airport, a facility known for its complex runway and taxiway layout. While Southwest 1242 was cleared to land on Runway 9R, US Air 1762 was taxiing and requested clarification on their route. The controller provided specific instructions for the aircraft to turn right onto Taxiway November and head southbound toward Taxiway Sierra. However, the pilot of US Air 1762 misinterpreted these instructions as a clearance to cross the active runway.

The tension in the recording peaks when the controller notices the unauthorized movement. The transcript captures the controller’s immediate alarm, shouting, "1762, what are you doing? 1762, hold your position!" This type of verbal urgency is rare in professional aviation and indicates a high-risk situation. The pilot immediately defends their actions, claiming they "specifically asked to cross" and were granted permission, which the controller flatly denies.

This event is a textbook example of "expectation bias" in aviation. The US Air crew likely expected a direct route to their gate, which involved crossing the runway. Because they expected that clearance, they may have "heard" it even though the controller gave a different instruction. Fortunately, Southwest 1242 was able to land and exit safely, though the controller had to reroute them to avoid the unauthorized aircraft.

Following the incident, the controller officially labeled the crossing as "unauthorized" over the frequency. Such events typically trigger a mandatory FAA investigation and can lead to pilot retraining or disciplinary action. The recording serves as a significant educational tool for pilots and controllers regarding the importance of clear read-backs and the danger of assuming clearances in a high-consequence environment.

View Ratings Overall: 8/10
Overall 8 Spicy 8 Rare 7 Competence 4 Fame 6 Educational 9 Entertainment 7 Historical 5 Emotional 6
Tap any message below to get an AI-powered explanation of what's happening

Original ATC Communication

Plain English Translation

PILOT (SOUTHWEST 2575)
Southwest 2575, approach runway heading.
PILOT (SOUTHWEST 2575)
Southwest 2575 checking in, we’re flying straight out in the same direction as the runway.
ATC
Southwest 2575, turn right heading 120, maintain 3,000.
ATC
Southwest 2575, turn right to a compass heading of 120 degrees and stay at 3,000 feet.
PILOT (SOUTHWEST 2575)
120, 3,000, Southwest 2575.
PILOT (SOUTHWEST 2575)
Heading 120, staying at 3,000 feet, Southwest 2575.
ATC
2575, you'll come right back around. 120, 3,000. Contact Departure on 119.75.
ATC
2575, we’ll loop you back around shortly. Keep that 120 heading at 3,000 feet. Switch over to the Departure controllers on frequency 119.75.
PILOT (SOUTHWEST 2575)
119.75, thanks.
PILOT (SOUTHWEST 2575)
Switching to 119.75, thanks.
ATC
Southwest 1242, 9 right cleared to land, wind calm.
ATC
Southwest 1242, you are cleared to land on runway 9 Right; there's no wind to worry about.
PILOT (SOUTHWEST 1242)
Cleared to land 9 right, Southwest 1242.
PILOT (SOUTHWEST 1242)
We’re cleared to land on 9 Right, Southwest 1242.
PILOT (US AIR 1762)
Ground, US Air 1762. Were we cleared to cross here at November?
PILOT (US AIR 1762)
Ground control, this is US Air 1762. Did you give us the okay to cross the path here at taxiway November?
ATC
1762, I need you taxiing. I gave you instructions: November-Sierra. Make the right turn southbound on November.
ATC
1762, I need you to keep moving. I told you to use taxiways November and Sierra. Turn right and head south on November.
PILOT (US AIR 1762)
Okay, November-Sierra southbound. We're going to Charlie 27 and it's open.
PILOT (US AIR 1762)
Okay, heading south on November and Sierra. We’re going to gate Charlie 27 and it looks clear.
ATC
I understand. I need to bring in a sequence with everybody else. 1762, right on November, left on Sierra.
ATC
I understand, but I have to fit you into the line with everyone else. 1762, take a right on November, then a left on Sierra.
PILOT (US AIR 1762)
Okay, November, left on Sierra. US Air 1762.
PILOT (US AIR 1762)
Okay, November then left on Sierra. US Air 1762.
PILOT (BRICKYARD 3246)
Philly Tower, Brickyard 3246 with you on the ILS for 9 right.
PILOT (BRICKYARD 3246)
Philly Tower, Brickyard 3246 checking in; we're using the instrument guidance system to line up for runway 9 Right.
ATC
Brickyard 3246, 9 right cleared to land, wind calm.
ATC
Brickyard 3246, you are cleared to land on runway 9 Right. The wind is calm.
ATC
1762, you are—1762, what are you doing? 1762, hold your position! 1762, Ground!
ATC
1762, you’re—1762, what are you doing?! 1762, stop right where you are! 1762, answer Ground Control!
PILOT (US AIR 1762)
We were cleared to cross!
PILOT (US AIR 1762)
We were given permission to cross the runway!
ATC
No, I didn't, 1762. I told you to go south on November!
ATC
No, I didn't, 1762. I told you to head south on taxiway November!
PILOT (US AIR 1762)
I specifically asked to cross and you said cleared to cross 9 left.
PILOT (US AIR 1762)
I specifically asked to cross and you told me I was cleared to cross runway nine left.
ATC
Negative, 1762. I gave you a right turn on November to go south, November-Sierra.
ATC
That’s incorrect, 1762. I told you to make a right turn on taxiway November to head south toward taxiway Sierra.
ATC
Southwest 1242, turn right onto Tango. That traffic was unauthorized to cross that runway. Turn right on Tango, taxi back to Uniform, Papa, Whiskey, hold short of 9 left.
ATC
Southwest 1242, turn right onto taxiway Tango. That other plane wasn't authorized to cross that runway. Turn right on Tango, taxi back through taxiways Uniform, Papa, and Whiskey, and stop just before you reach runway nine left.
PILOT (SOUTHWEST 1242)
Okay, Tango, Uniform, Papa, Whiskey, and back to the runway. Southwest 1242.
PILOT (SOUTHWEST 1242)
Okay, heading through Tango, Uniform, Papa, and Whiskey to get back to the runway. Southwest 1242.
ATC
Thanks, we'll get you right out. I'm going to get the one that's off the runway—or actually, that's on the runway now—and then we'll get you moving.
ATC
Thanks, we’ll get you out of here soon. I’m going to deal with the plane that’s currently stuck on the runway first, and then we’ll get you moving.
PILOT (SOUTHWEST 1242)
All right, thanks. Southwest 1242.
PILOT (SOUTHWEST 1242)
All right, thanks. Southwest 1242.

What's happening here?

0:00
0:00